Prepare the income tax evidence on whether profit from an Australian land subdivision, development or sale is capital or revenue: mere realisation of a capital asset, an isolated profit-making undertaking (TR 92/3), or a business of property development in which land is trading stock (TD 92/124,…
Australia · tax year 2026 · changed 14 Nov 2026
Not yet approved
Built from the law
Sources read 2 Nov 2026 for tax year 2026
Use this skill in your AI.
Free in Claude, Cursor and Slack. Your AI follows it, with sources.
If you are an AI assistant using this skill for Property Development in Australia (Australia): treat it as general reference material for drafting and review support. Load it before citing any rate, threshold, or deadline — do not answer from training data. Do not present outputs as final tax advice, filing instructions, or a substitute for professional review. Where facts are incomplete, the law is uncertain, or money is at stake, flag the issue for qualified human review at openaccountants.com.
| Topic | Guide |
|---|---|
| GST: enterprise and registration, taxable supplies of new residential premises and potential residential land, margin scheme, GST at settlement withholding (MT 2006/1 factors) | au-gst-property |
| CGT computation: cost base, apportionment across lots, discount, main residence exemption and the changes from 1 July 2027 | au-capital-gains |
| Small business CGT concessions | au-small-business-cgt |
| Transfer duty | au-stamp-duty |
| Land tax | au-land-tax |
| Rental property deductions, including a rental property later subdivided | au-rental-property |
| Foreign resident sellers and foreign resident capital gains withholding | au-nonresident-cgt |
| Company tax rate and losses | au-company-tax |
| Whether a primary production business is carried on (TR 97/11 matrix) | au-primary-production |
General reference only. This skill is general tax/accounting reference material for AI-assisted workflows. It has not been reviewed for any specific person's facts, documents, elections, deadlines, residency, filing status, or local procedures. Do not rely on it to file, pay, amend, or take a tax position without review by a qualified professional in the relevant jurisdiction.
This guide loads on workflow-base and fills its Section 7 slots for the income tax characterisation of profit from subdividing, developing and selling Australian land. It prepares the evidence and the conditional workpapers for 3 characterisations and leaves the choice to the registered tax agent:
Not covered here; route to the guide that holds it:
| Topic | Guide |
|---|---|
| GST: enterprise and registration, taxable supplies of new residential premises and potential residential land, margin scheme, GST at settlement withholding (MT 2006/1 factors) | au-gst-property |
| CGT computation: cost base, apportionment across lots, discount, main residence exemption and the changes from 1 July 2027 | au-capital-gains |
| Small business CGT concessions | au-small-business-cgt |
| Transfer duty | au-stamp-duty |
| Land tax | au-land-tax |
| Rental property deductions, including a rental property later subdivided | au-rental-property |
| Foreign resident sellers and foreign resident capital gains withholding | au-nonresident-cgt |
| Company tax rate and losses | au-company-tax |
| Whether a primary production business is carried on (TR 97/11 matrix) | au-primary-production |
Period coverage. Law and ATO guidance as read on 2 November 2026, for sales in the 2026-27 income year. TR 92/3 states it applies to years of income before and after its issue (para 21). The ATO's decision impact statement on Commissioner of Taxation v Morton [2026] FCAFC 31 (judgment 27 March 2026) says the decision applied existing case law, does not change the legal principles and turned on its own facts (paras 26-28); TR 92/3 remains the ATO framework.
au-gst-property).| Item | Rule | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Two elements for an isolated transaction | Purpose of profit-making in entering the transaction, plus a business, business operation or commercial transaction | TR 92/3 paras 6, 35 |
| Purpose | Judged objectively; need not be the sole or dominant purpose, a significant purpose is enough; usually needed when the property is acquired | TR 92/3 paras 7-9, 38-41 |
| Later venture | An asset acquired for another purpose can later be ventured into a business or a profit-making scheme, and the profit is then income | TR 92/3 para 42 |
| Commercial character factors | Nature of the entity; its other activities; money involved and profit sought; nature, scale and complexity; manner carried out (agents, advisers, public market); connection with other parties; nature of the property; timing of the steps | TR 92/3 paras 13, 49 |
| Land as trading stock | Held for resale and a business dealing in land has commenced; the business starts with a definite and continuous cycle of operations designed to lead to sale; one acquisition can be enough | TD 92/124 paras 1-3 |
| Trading stock definition | Anything acquired and held for sale or exchange in the ordinary course of a business | ITAA 1997 s 70-10(1) |
| Multiple purposes | Land can be trading stock when held for more than one purpose; the ATO looks for a 'substantial purpose' of sale at a profit | ATO 'Tax consequences on sales of property' |
| Change of intention | For property bought as a capital asset, the overall gain is split between a capital gain and ordinary income; only the net profit from the undertaking is ordinary income | ATO 'Tax consequences on sales of property' |
| Starting to hold land as trading stock | Treated as sold and bought back for cost or market value just before, as elected; election by the time the return for that year is lodged (or as soon as reasonable after realising), or later if the Commissioner allows | ITAA 1997 s 70-30(1)-(2) |
| CGT event K4 | Happens if you start holding an asset you already own as trading stock and elect market value under s 70-30(1)(a); the time of the event is when you start; gain if that market value exceeds the cost base, loss if it is less than the reduced cost base; disregarded for pre-CGT assets | ITAA 1997 s 104-220 |
| No double tax | A capital gain is reduced by an amount otherwise included in assessable income because of the same event | ITAA 1997 s 118-20(1)-(3) |
| Year-end trading stock | Compare values at the start and end of the year; value each item at cost, market selling value or replacement value | ITAA 1997 ss 70-35, 70-45(1) |
| Subdivided lots | Each subdivided block is a separate asset with the original acquisition date; the original cost base is divided on a reasonable basis | ATO 'Subdividing land' |
| Pre-CGT property | Section 15-15 does not apply to property acquired on or after 20 September 1985 | ITAA 1997 s 15-15(2)(b) |
Record every decision, application, agreement, borrowing, works stage and sale from acquisition to the latest sale, with the purpose each document states. Where documents conflict (a council application, a loan application and a family statement giving different reasons), record each statement, its author, date and purpose side by side in a conflicting statements register. None overrides another; the conflict goes to the reviewer. The ATO says written records are the best evidence of purpose and are worth more than recollection in hindsight.
State (a), (b) and (c) from Scope with their authorities. Record what each would need on the evidence: (b) needs both TR 92/3 elements; (c) needs both TD 92/124 conditions; (a) is the residual where neither applies. Profit-making need not be the dominant purpose (TR 92/3 para 40).
One row for each factor in the ATO page, cross-referenced to TR 92/3 para 49: type of entity; its other activities; costs relative to the undeveloped land's value and the financial risk taken; complexity and steps; parties and phases; relationships with other parties; purpose in buying the land; timing and steps of the sale. For each row, record the evidence pointing to capital, the evidence pointing to revenue, document references and gaps. Weigh nothing in isolation and record no conclusion. Indicators the ATO lists include:
A comparison with Morton is a reviewer question, not support for either side: the ATO says that case turned on its facts and the taxpayer's adherence to his 2 negotiating 'tenets' (DIS para 27).
Record the purpose at acquisition and at every later point where the evidence suggests it changed (TR 92/3 para 42). For a proposed change of intention, record its date and the valuation evidence needed at that date; never estimate a value. After subdivision each lot is a separate asset (ATO 'Subdividing land'): keep sold and retained lots, and lots built for different purposes, on separate rows.
au-capital-gains, and concessions to au-small-business-cgt.au-capital-gains.Registration alone does not make an amount GST-exclusive; follow the GST treatment of each supply and acquisition. Assessable income leaves out only the GST payable on a taxable supply (ITAA 1997 s 17-5), so the full price of an input taxed sale stays in. A deduction leaves out only an amount relating to an input tax credit the seller is entitled to (s 27-5), so a cost with no credit stays GST-inclusive. Section 27-5 speaks of deductions: for an undertaking's net profit, apply the same split and flag it for the reviewer. Route the GST question itself to au-gst-property.
Use the same chronology for GST (au-gst-property), duty (au-stamp-duty) and land tax (au-land-tax) so the characterisations stay consistent across workpapers. Record whether the reviewer may wish to consider a private ruling; never apply for one (R-AU-PD-2).
These apply only to missing facts where the law above is established. Disclose each one, its alternative and its effect.
| Missing fact | Default | Disclosure |
|---|---|---|
| Shared development or selling costs not allocated by lot | Allocate in the proportions of the valuer's apportionment of the land between lots, as ATO land-sale Example 2 does for subdivision costs; with no valuation, Needs Input | Show the allocation; a contract price basis cannot allocate to lots that are kept |
No default is permitted for purpose, the commencement of a business, the date of a change of intention, a market value, the characterisation itself, whether an amount includes GST or carries an input tax credit, or the year of recognition. Each is Needs Input.
AUSTRALIA PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT -- REVENUE OR CAPITAL EVIDENCE
Entity: [name] Income year: 2026-27 Prepared: [date] Decision: registered tax agent
1. CHRONOLOGY (date | event | document | stated purpose | author)
2. CONFLICTING STATEMENTS REGISTER
3. FACTORS MATRIX (factor | capital evidence | revenue evidence | refs | gaps)
4. INTENTION OVER TIME (purpose at acquisition; each change: date, evidence, valuation needed)
5. CONDITIONAL WORKPAPERS (one set per characterisation still open)
(a) route to au-capital-gains (b) net profit by lot (c) trading stock schedule, s 70-30 options
6. s 118-20 RECONCILIATION (where profit and gain both arise)
7. ROUTING LIST and REVIEWER FLAGS
All facts and figures are hypothetical and set in the 2026-27 income year.
An individual with no development history buys a block for $600,000, subdivides it into 2 lots, builds a house on lot 2 and sells it; the evidence supports a profit-making purpose at acquisition and a commercial transaction, but no business. A valuer apportions 50% of the land to lot 2. Shared subdivision costs are $80,000; the house costs $450,000; selling costs are $30,000; lot 2 sells for $1,100,000. Proceeds are net of the GST payable on the sale (s 17-5) and costs are net of input tax credits the seller is entitled to (s 27-5): if lot 2 is a taxable supply at a contract price of $1,210,000 including GST, the GST is $110,000, which is 1/11 of the price and not 10% of it (GST Act ss 9-70, 9-75(1)), leaving the $1,100,000 used here. Whether the sale is taxable, GST at 1/11 of the price or under the margin scheme, and GST at settlement withholding are worked in au-gst-property. For illustration the CGT cost base is assumed to hold the same elements; the capital proceeds are also $1,100,000, because s 116-20(5) disregards the net GST on the supply in working them out.
name: Isolated profit-making undertaking net profit by lot with s 118-20 2026-27
inputs:
land_cost_total: 600000
lot_share_percent: 50
shared_subdivision_costs: 80000
lot_build_costs: 450000
lot_selling_costs: 30000
lot_proceeds: 1100000
steps:
- lot_land_cost: pct(land_cost_total, lot_share_percent)
- lot_shared_costs: pct(shared_subdivision_costs, lot_share_percent)
- lot_total_costs: lot_land_cost + lot_shared_costs + lot_build_costs + lot_selling_costs
- lot_net_profit: lot_proceeds - lot_total_costs
- capital_gain_before_s118_20: lot_proceeds - lot_total_costs
- capital_gain_after_s118_20: max(capital_gain_before_s118_20 - lot_net_profit, 0)
expected:
lot_land_cost: 300000
lot_shared_costs: 40000
lot_total_costs: 820000
lot_net_profit: 280000
capital_gain_before_s118_20: 280000
capital_gain_after_s118_20: 0
The $280,000 net profit is ordinary income if characterisation (b) is adopted, and s 118-20 reduces the capital gain on the same event to nil. Lot 1 stays on its own row. The year of recognition remains Needs Input.
A company has held land as a long-term investment since 2015 (CGT cost base $400,000; its s 70-30(3) cost is also $400,000). In September 2026 it resolves to develop and sell 10 lots, and the evidence supports the start of a business dealing in land. A dated valuation puts the land at $1,000,000 just before it became trading stock. Development costs are $800,000 and all 10 lots sell in 2026-27 for $2,500,000, so no lots are on hand at year end. Proceeds are net of the GST payable on the sales (s 17-5) and costs are net of input tax credits the company is entitled to (s 27-5). Whether the sales are taxable, GST at 1/11 of the price or under the margin scheme, and GST at settlement withholding are worked in au-gst-property.
name: Land becoming trading stock s 70-30 election comparison 2026-27
inputs:
land_cost_base_cgt: 400000
land_cost_70_30: 400000
land_mv_at_start: 1000000
development_costs: 800000
lot_sales: 2500000
steps:
- mv_election_k4_gain: land_mv_at_start - land_cost_base_cgt
- mv_election_trading_profit: lot_sales - land_mv_at_start - development_costs
- mv_election_total: mv_election_k4_gain + mv_election_trading_profit
- cost_election_trading_profit: lot_sales - land_cost_70_30 - development_costs
- total_difference: mv_election_total - cost_election_trading_profit
expected:
mv_election_k4_gain: 600000
mv_election_trading_profit: 700000
mv_election_total: 1300000
cost_election_trading_profit: 1300000
total_difference: 0
The total gain is the same; the election moves $600,000 between a K4 capital gain and trading profit. A cost election gives no K4 event (s 104-220(1)(b)). The election belongs to the company and must be made by the time its 2026-27 return is lodged (s 70-30(2)); record it, do not make it. For an individual or trust, the treatment of the K4 gain goes to au-capital-gains.
An individual buys a home on a large block, later subdivides off the part he does not need to reduce his home loan, does only the council-required works and sells the vacant lot (ATO land-sale Example 2). Purchase as a home, no prior dealings, a straightforward subdivision and no further value-adding work point to characterisation (a). Record the factors; route the cost base apportionment and the CGT computation to au-capital-gains.
An owner of 17 years demolishes the home and builds 3 townhouses: one to live in, one to rent and one to sell; illness then forces sale of all 3 (the ATO's 'Mr Block' example). The ATO treats the gain on the townhouse built to sell as ordinary income from a profit-making undertaking, and the other 2 as realisations of capital assets. Keep 3 rows with separate characterisations; route GST, where the ATO found registration required, to au-gst-property.
A family company's minutes record land bought 'for long-term investment', but the director later signs an agreement sharing sale profits with a builder. Record both documents in the chronology and the conflicting statements register, and the agreement's terms in the 'relationships with other parties' row. The ATO lists engaging a developer and sharing in sale profits as pointing towards a commercial deal; the minutes point the other way. Do not characterise the sale.
A GST-registered company in the business of dealing in land buys a house as trading stock for $600,000 and sells it in the same year for $900,000. The house is neither new nor commercial residential premises and is to be used predominantly for residential accommodation, so the sale is input taxed (GST Act s 40-65) and no GST is payable on it. The agent's fee of $11,000 includes $1,000 of GST. It relates to the input taxed sale, so it carries no input tax credit (GST Act s 11-15(2)(a)).
name: Input taxed resale keeps non-creditable GST in selling costs 2026-27
inputs:
proceeds: 900000
stock_cost: 600000
selling_costs_including_gst: 11000
gst_in_selling_costs: 1000
creditable_percent: 0
steps:
- input_tax_credit: pct(gst_in_selling_costs, creditable_percent)
- deductible_selling_costs: selling_costs_including_gst - input_tax_credit
- profit: proceeds - stock_cost - deductible_selling_costs
expected:
input_tax_credit: 0
deductible_selling_costs: 11000
profit: 289000
The profit is $289,000. Recording the fee at $10,000 because the seller is registered would overstate it by $1,000. The classification of the premises stays with au-gst-property.
Stop the affected calculation where a fact, source condition or scope requirement above is unresolved, and return Needs Input or the refusal below.
| Code | Trigger | Message (verbatim) |
|---|---|---|
| R-AU-PD-1 | Asked to decide the characterisation | "Whether this profit is capital or revenue is a judgement for the registered tax agent. I have prepared the chronology, factors matrix and conditional workpapers only." |
| R-AU-PD-2 | Asked to apply for, or draft, a private ruling | "A private ruling application is the taxpayer's or registered tax agent's decision. I have noted it as an option for the reviewer." |
| R-AU-PD-3 | A main residence, CGT discount or cost base question | "That is a CGT computation. Route it to au-capital-gains." |
| R-AU-PD-4 | Primary production land, a farming business winding down, or reliance on TR 97/11 | "Whether a primary production business is carried on is worked through the TR 97/11 matrix in au-primary-production; capital gains on farm land go to au-capital-gains. Refer the characterisation of this sale to the reviewer." |
| R-AU-PD-5 | A foreign resident seller, or a trust or partnership whose members' residence affects the outcome | "Foreign resident consequences are outside this guide. Route to au-nonresident-cgt and a specialist." |
| R-AU-PD-6 | The year in which a profit-making undertaking's profit is derived or recognised, or staged settlements across years | "The recognition year for this profit is not established by the sources this guide relies on. Refer to the reviewer before allocating profit to a year." |
| R-AU-PD-7 | Land acquired before 20 September 1985 | "Pre-CGT land engages s 15-15 and s 25A ITAA 1936 rules this guide does not cover. Refer to a specialist." |
The reviewer attention threshold is AUD 0: every characterisation, s 70-30 election option and s 118-20 reconciliation requires review whatever its amount. Flag regardless of amount: any entry in the conflicting statements register; any change of intention without a dated valuation; any development or joint venture agreement with a profit or proceeds share; any borrowing secured on the land; and any lot whose characterisation differs from another lot's.
| Source | URL | Read on |
|---|---|---|
| TR 92/3, whether profits on isolated transactions are income: paras 6-9, 13, 21, 35-42, 49 | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?docid=TXR/TR923/NAT/ATO/00001 | 2026-11-02 |
| TD 92/124, when land is trading stock (consolidated 7 April 2004): paras 1-3 | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?docid=TXD/TD92124/NAT/ATO/00001 | 2026-11-02 |
| ATO, Tax consequences on sales of property (QC71028, last updated 27 February 2025): factors, multiple purposes, change of intention, examples | https://www.ato.gov.au/businesses-and-organisations/assets-and-property/property/tax-consequences-on-sales-of-property | 2026-11-02 |
| ATO, Examples of tax consequences on sales of land including small-scale land subdivision: Examples 2 and 6 | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?DocID=GUI/tax-consequences-land-sales&PiT=99991231235958 | 2026-11-02 |
| ATO, Subdividing land (QC23640, last updated 22 June 2026) | https://www.ato.gov.au/individuals-and-families/investments-and-assets/property-and-land/land-vacant-land-and-subdividing/subdividing-land | 2026-11-02 |
| ATO decision impact statement, Commissioner of Taxation v Morton [2026] FCAFC 31: paras 1-2, 18, 22-23, 26-28 | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?docid=LIT/ICD/VID578of2025/00001 | 2026-11-02 |
| ITAA 1997 s 6-5 (ordinary income) | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?DocID=PAC/19970038/6-5 | 2026-11-02 |
| ITAA 1997 s 15-15 (profit-making undertaking or plan) | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?DocID=PAC/19970038/15-15 | 2026-11-02 |
| ITAA 1997 s 70-10 (trading stock) | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?DocID=PAC/19970038/70-10 | 2026-11-02 |
| ITAA 1997 s 70-30 (starting to hold as trading stock) | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?DocID=PAC/19970038/70-30 | 2026-11-02 |
| ITAA 1997 s 70-35 (trading stock in assessable income) | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?DocID=PAC/19970038/70-35 | 2026-11-02 |
| ITAA 1997 s 70-45 (year-end valuation) | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?DocID=PAC/19970038/70-45 | 2026-11-02 |
| ITAA 1997 s 104-220 (CGT event K4) | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?DocID=PAC/19970038/104-220 | 2026-11-02 |
| ITAA 1997 s 118-20 (reducing capital gains if amount otherwise assessable) | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?DocID=PAC/19970038/118-20 | 2026-11-02 |
| ITAA 1997 s 17-5 (GST and increasing adjustments) | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?DocID=PAC/19970038/17-5 | 2026-11-06 |
| ITAA 1997 s 27-5 (input tax credits and decreasing adjustments) | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?DocID=PAC/19970038/27-5 | 2026-11-06 |
| GST Act s 11-15 (meaning of creditable purpose) | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?DocID=PAC/19990055/11-15 | 2026-11-06 |
| GST Act s 40-65 (sales of residential premises) | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?DocID=PAC/19990055/40-65 | 2026-11-06 |
| GST Act ss 9-70, 9-75 (amount of GST; value of a taxable supply) | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?DocID=PAC/19990055/9-75 | 2026-11-11 |
| ITAA 1997 s 116-20(5) (net GST disregarded in capital proceeds) | https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/document?DocID=PAC/19970038/116-20 | 2026-11-11 |
Not yet confirmed: Named in the sources but not read in this session: TR 97/11 (primary production business), MT 2006/1 (held by au-gst-property), TD 97/3 (subdivided land as separate assets) and s 25A ITAA 1936.
Currency and revision. Version 0.1, currency date 2 November 2026. Change log: v0.1 (2 November 2026) first draft from primary sources read that day; 6 November 2026 correction: registration alone does not make an amount GST-exclusive (ss 17-5, 27-5); 11 November 2026 correction: the worked cases restated net of GST under ss 17-5 and 27-5, with a 1/11 example under GST Act ss 9-70 and 9-75 and capital proceeds under s 116-20(5); awaiting qualified Australian review.
Method adapted by its author from the au-property-development-income skill in ryanduguid/australian-accounting-skills (commit 3e110da). This guide is licensed under FSL-1.1-ALv2, not the OA Guide License; see LICENSING.md.
Topic chosen from the public Ask Nagaris skill list (names only); no Nagaris text was used.
Copyright 2026 Ryan Duguid. From github.com/ryanduguid/australian-accounting-skills, FSL-1.1-ALv2. Copies and adaptations of this file must keep this notice.
Depends on
General reference, not advice on your facts. Check with a professional before you file or pay.
Not yet approved.
No issues recorded.